Joseph Angel b 1830 Madison Co KY m. Catherine Gabbard b 1827 Clay Co KY d 1864 Breathitt Co KY d/o Michael Gabbard and Mary Margaret Peters; m. Children of Joseph Angel and Catherine Gabbard;

1. Margaret Angel b 1849

2. Mary Angel b 1852

3. Ellen Angel b about 1854

4. Lucinda Angel b 25 Dec 1855 m. Claiborne Gilbert b 18 Jan 1850 d 22 Jul 1916 s/o Isaac Gilbert and Rebecca Gabbard.

5. Minerva Angel b 1856

6. Susan Angel