Shade Frazier
and Mary Frazier

Shade Frazier b 27 Dec 1881 Smootcreek, Letcher Co KY d 23 Aug 1960 Letcher Co KY; buried Shade Frazier Cemetery, Premium, Letcher Co KY; s/o Jonathon H Jont Frazier and Leodicia Dicy Combs. Shade Frazier m. 24 Mar 1901 Letcher Co KY to Mary Frazier b 28 Aug 1881 Letcher Co KY d 5/6 Dec 1968 Letcher Co KY; buried Shade Frazier Cemetery, Premium, Letcher Co KY; d/o Bonargen N Frazier and Nancy Frazier. Children of Shade Frazier and Mary Frazier;

1. Arlie Frazier b 24 Jun 1903 d 16 Jun 1932; abe 28; buried Shade Frazier Cemetery, Premium, Letcher Co KY; m. 23 Oct 1924 to Alberta Collins.

2. Rosa Frazier b 15 Dec 1905; m. John Adams.

3. Nora Frazier b 16 Jan 1907 Letcher Co KY d 30 Dec 2006; age 99; Saint Clair Shores, Macomb Co Michigan; buried Cadillac Memorial Gardens East, Clinton Twp, Macomb Co Michigan; m. 1925 to Willard Combs b 2 Jun 1893 d 19 Oct 1970; age 77; buried Green Acres Cemetery, Ermine, Letcher Co KY. Willard Combs m. 5 Mar 1913 Letcher Co KY to Bertha Pendleton b 8 Aug 1894 d 8 Apr 1921; age 26; of typhoid; Letcher Co KY; buried Sergent Cemetery, Whitesburg, Letcher Co KY; d/o Joseph Delaware Pendleton and Cyntha M Blair. Children of Willard Combs and Bertha Pendleton; i. Emmett Earle Combs b 11 Oct 1913 KY d 19 Jan 1991; age 77; Riverside Co CA; buried Riverside National Cemetery, Riverside, Riverside Co CA; m. Blanche Smallwood b 26 Apr 1923 Boyle Co KY d 12 Aug 2016; age 93; Riverside Co CA; buried Riverside National Cemetery, Riverside, Riverside Co CA, Section 14 - Site 596; d/o Enoch Smallwood and Daisy Mullins.

4. Verna Frazier b 15 Feb 1910 d 16 Oct 1931; buried Shade Frazier Cemetery, Premium, Letcher Co KY;

5. Mae Frazier b 26 Jan 1912 Letcher Co KY d 6 Nov 1994; age 82; Chantilly, Fairfax Co VA; buried Shade Frazier Cemetery, Letcher Co KY; m. 9 Dec 1933 to Carl Whitaker b 26 Sept 1908 d 18 Sept 1971; buried Shade Frazier Cemetery, Premium, Letcher Co KY. Child of Carl Whitaker and Mae Frazier; i. Donald Gay Whitaker b 31 Oct 1934 Letcher Co KY d 19 Jan 1947; age 12; Letcher Co KY; buried Shade Frazier Cemetery, Letcher Co KY.

6. Orvel Frazier b 18 May 1914 d 31 Jan 1992; age 77; buried Shade Frazier Cemetery, Premium, Letcher Co KY; m. 16 Sept 1941 to Beulah Barnett b 18 Nov 1920 d 12 Nov 1955; buried Shade Frazier Cemetery, Premium, Letcher Co KY.

7. Wise Slemp Frazier; m. Anna Hunter Frymire.

8. Lona Frazier b 9 Sept 1920 d 18 Oct 1997; age 77; buried Shade Frazier Cemetery, Premium, Letcher Co KY; m. Patrick Blair. Lona Frazier; m. Male Johnson.

9. Shade Frazier; m. Hudson Goins.


More About Shade Frazier

Shade Frazier and Mary Frazier lived on Kingdom Come Creek until about 1920 when coal mining started at Elsiecoal (Hot Spot) they moved to Smoot Creek near Shade's childhood home where they lived ever since. Shade was a farmer and a merchant. He inherited his farm from his parents. He owned and managed a general store at Roxanna, KY, and provided well for his family. He was a soft-spoken, kind and friendly man.


LOVE AFFAIR ENDS IN TRAGEDY
Mountain Eagle Newspaper
Whitesburg, Letcher Co KY
22 Oct 1931 Page 1

One of the most lamentable and sensational killing affairs took place at Elsiecoal, on Smoot Creek, in our county on last Friday evening. Dewey Brashears, 27, a well known and said to be highly respected young man, and Miss Verna Frazier, 22, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Shade Frazier, a sweet and happy young woman and one of the Elsiecoal teachers, had been sweethearts, but it is said had decided owing to a falling out to not remain so any longer, though the young man was still persistent in pushing his love affair. On the evening mention Brashears drove up the creek to near the school building and waited for the school to end the day's session. When this took place, Miss Frazier got in the car and rode off up the creek with him, toward home. They evidently quarreled or disagreed about something for when only a short distance from her home, Brashears stopped the car, got out of it and fired two shots into the car, instantly killing the young woman. This done, he turned the pistol on himself and fired, the ball entering the left breast just above the heart, inflicting what looked to be a fatal wound.

The young man was quickly brought to Whitesburg where Doctors Combs and Collier examined him, each believing the wound fatal, but he was dispatched to the hospital at Seco, where on Monday Dr. Moss says his chances for recovery are good. A guard is keeping watch over him.

Miss Frazier was one of the most popular young women in the county, well along in her college work and with bright hopes for a successful career before her. She was highly connected with several of our best and leading families and her death, so sadly brought about, has brought about a profound sensation and grief. Her assailant, Dewey Brashears, is a son of Ezekial Brashears residing near Coolidge, Perry County. He has been employed as operator for the L. & N. railroad for a number of years, but at the time of the killing was not so employed. The Brashears family is one of the leading Perry County families.

On Sunday, in the presence of hundreds of friends and relatives, the funeral was held at the home of her parents on Smoot Creek, Elder Bennett Adams and others officiating. Soon after interment took place in the family cemetery near her home. The Eagle joins the many friends in offering its sympathies.


Dewey Brashears Gets Death Sentence
Slayer of Miss Verna Frazier
Given Highest Penalty - Death
Mt Eagle Newspaper, Whitesburg, KY, 28 Jan 1932

In the afternoon on Tuesday the case of Dewey Brashears, 28, charged with the murder of Miss Verna Frazier, 21, a young lady teacher, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Shade Frazier, was called for trial. Both the Commonwealth and defense announced ready and preparation for empanneling a jury to try the case was started. Very soon in the evening eight of the regular venire had qualified and accepted by both sides. Sheriff Potter was directed to summon thirty other men from the upper end of the county from which to secure the other required four to complete the panel. On Wednesday morning the jury was completed and sworn. It consists of the following, all rather middle aged men: Sam Bentley, John Arrington, Marion Amburgey, Broas Wright, Elihu Blair (Colly), M. H. Boone, U. S. Tolliver, Lee Thomas, A. C. Brown, Frank Cornett, Sandy Adams and Robert Thomas.

Not in many years in Letcher County has any case tried in Circuit Court Attracted such wide-spread interest as this case has. From the time the case was called the courthouse has been blocked and jammed with persons anxious to hear every word spoken. Dewey Brashears is a son of Ezekiel Brashears, a well known and highly respected citizen of Perry County and a member of one of the oldest and best known. Dewey is a well educated and a former telegraph operator on the L&N railroad, and so far as known, had borne an excellent reputation. Miss Frazier, the young lady shot and killed, was a popular school teacher, well educated and a daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Shade Frazier, members of one of our largest and most highly respected families.

Readers of the Eagle, as well as hundreds of our citizens, will recall this sad affair in which Miss Frazier was shot and killed while seated in an automobile on Smoot Creek near her home and near the school building in which she had taught, on October 16, 1931. Brashears, it is alleged, after quarreling with Miss Frazier, his alleged sweet-heart got out of the car and fired two shots into it, killing her. He then turned the pistol upon himself and fired, the ball pasing through his body and barely missing his heart. He was quickly gathered into a truck and taken to the hospital at Seco, where he survived his wound. In two weeks he was able to leave the hospital and was brought to jail here, where he has been ever since.

The Commonwealth's side of the case is being handled by States Attorney A. O. Stump, assisted by County Attorney Astor Hogg, D. I. Day, and Stephen Combs, Jr. French Hawk and A. J. Kirk have charge of the defense. The Commonwealth will undertake to prove a case of premeditated murder and ask for the highest penalty. The defense will plead insanity on the part of the defendant. No less than fifty witnesses have been called and are on hand to testify. A number of relatives and interested parties are on hand from Perry County.

The Comonwealth first used Mr. Frazier, the girl's father, who testified regarding the death of his daughter and exhibited the bloody clothes owrn by her at the time she was shot. He was followed by other witnesses who saw the shooting or heard the shots. One of these witnesses testified that Brashears got out of the car with a pistol and with his face slightly turned away, fired the two shots and then walked around the car and fired one shot into his own breast. Dr. Moss, one of the physicians in charge of the Seco hospital, testified that when Brashears was brought to the hospital he was suffering severely, had lost a good deal of blood and was semi-conscious. That only after supplying glucose to restore his blood was he able to talk. That when he told him he could hardly survive he said that Miss Frazier got the gun from the back of the car, shot him and after that he could hardly remember. He also was asked as to his experience and study of insane persons. In this Dr. Moss was asked to go into details which he did. Dr. M. E Combs, Hazard physician, also testified for the defense as to the sanity of Brashears. Various witnesses from the neighborhood in which he was reared and who knew Brashears stated that insanity was common in the family.

Throughout the trial and the taking of evidence the defendant sat quietly, twitching his thumbs and monifested no interest in his fate. Never did he consult his attorneys, nor did they consult with him. Evidence in the case was continued until just before noon today when both sides announced themselves through with the evidence. Instructions were prepared and read by the court to the jury. Regular instructions in such cases were given, including the charge of insanity. The latter charge, if found by the jury, would necissitate a verdict of not guilty and then he would be committed to an insane asylum.

The case was ably argued by States Attorney Stump and County Attorney Astor Hogg for the Commonwealth, Kirk and Hawk for the defense. Mr. Stump and Mr. Hogg plead for the highest penalty, which is death or a life sentence, while Mr. Kirk and Mr. Hawk based all their arguments on the insanity plea. During the arguments there was not even standing and scarcely breathing room in the court room. The defendant still sat stark and apparently disinterested in what was going on.

Late in the evening the jury retired for a verdict. In a little over ten minutes the jury walked into the courtroom and took its seat. A deathly silence pervaded. "Gentlemen, have you agreed on a verdict?" said Judge Fields. "We have," came the reply. Again there was tense silence as one of the jurors reached the indictment to the court. Judge Fields read, "We, the jury, do agree and find the defendant guilty as charged in the indictment and fix his punishment at death." For a full minute no one uttered a word. As the verdict was read, young Brashears slightly lifted his pale face to the court, opened rather wide his eyes and then settled back to his usual calm and quiet demeanor. Evidently the jury did not believe the insanity plea, and their quick arrival at a verdict showed this. Only once or twice before in the long history of Circuit Courts in Letcher county has such a verdict been rendered, and only a few times in the past has such an interest in the trial of a case been shown. There is little if any doubt but that the case will be appealed.


Top of Page

| Home | Links | Email | Feedback | Facebook | Guestbook | Rootsweb |
Go Back Copyright © Annette Potter Some Rights Reserved Go Forward